The Journey for truth and Avoiding Self Destruction
Reading Laurie
Sandell’s The Impostor’s Daughter was
an interesting experience because of the way it was formatted. There were
several places throughout the story where I was confused as to where it was going
and I thought that she had lost the thread of the story. But every time she
brought it back and with greater focus and understanding. I felt this most with
Ben and her interviews. I wondered at times why so much attention was paid to Ben
when this was a story about her father. It seemed that he was not all that
important to her. But then I realized that it was a chronical for her abuse of
Ambien and how she was an imposter of sorts in her relationship with Ben, and everything
made sense to me. And although I still feel a similar way about the interviews,
lots of name dropping, that too had a bigger picture, because that that led her
to meet the person that would light the way towards her road to recovery. That
too had a point.
Back to the
framing, I really appreciated the book end that Sandell created. I fully
believe that it was successful because of the form that is graphic memoir. I love
the last panel of the book and how it is a picture of the handwritten get it out
of your system writing that later became the first panel. That really seemed to
put everything together for me. Talk about great opening lines “Whenever my
father went out of town, he had the mail stopped. It didn’t matter if he was
gone for one, two or ten days—if my father wasn’t home, the mail didn’t come.” That
just pulls the reader in.
The pacing
of this memoir was interesting because it seemed to speed through childhood. Most
of the stories we have read spend a lot of time in those early days that shaped
us. Sandell really didn’t which fits because that who part was in part a lie. I
thought it was very interesting to spend so much time with an adult narrator.
But that too made sense because it is almost like her adult life up until the
time she goes into recovery is her “childhood.”
Something
else I really appreciated about this book was the way it dealt with time. When
Sandell lets the reader know how bad her Ambien abuse really had gotten,
falling asleep in the bathtub twice, I was taken aback. This moment is really
powerful, and it was made so by when it was revealed. Had that information come
out as it happened it would have the revelation feeling to it. This book is
about the reveling of information the hiding of it, truth and lies. Sandell
spends much of the book searching for who her father really is and we as
readers are on that journey with her. When we find out that she was holding
back on us too, not letting us know how bad she was doing. we feel cheated and
lied too. this allows us to further identify with her struggle to discover her
father. We also see what her search for him, for the truth has cost her. That
moment for me was the most griping emotionally. In those few pages she did what
her father was never able to do, face herself.
I feel like
I should spend some time talking about the reliability of the narrator in this book.
Because of the way Sandell laid out the Ambien use super slowly at first and
then openly but without saying it what it was it made me trust her. It felt
like she was giving me bits and pieces of the story and it was up to me to come
up with it. This again made me feel a part of the journey. I felt this most
when during the brief conversations between her and the PI, and when she received
letters from people. There was so much more there that I wanted to know. But
that wasn’t the point of the book to a certain degree. The point of the book
was about the cost of searching for the truth and what happens when you find it
and how you live with yourself and the people around you.
Great work on the timing and pace CF. the first time i read it, it fell into parts for me and like you i had to go back to get the whole feeling, the completeness of the narrative. You're right, we'll talk about reliability.
ReplyDeletee
Great observations around her focus on Ben. I feel like she was able to use the frames and visual aspects of the story to distract us during these moments. I felt like she was both not facing herself in those moments and then facing herself abruptly. I know I had several similar moments where I felt like she slammed on brakes and had us sit with a lot of raw emotions. Great point on reliability, too. I had a lot of mixed feelings about this aspect, which i hinted at in my write up.
ReplyDelete“Whenever my father went out of town, he had the mail stopped. It didn’t matter if he was gone for one, two or ten days—if my father wasn’t home, the mail didn’t come.” That just pulls the reader in.
ReplyDeleteI agree. This was surely a line that drew the reader in. A very mysterious line that immediately told us he had something to hide. Sandell had a great way of using the frame to zoom in and out of scene, as well as using them to shift gears. Also, I too agree that some of the book/scenes are "speedy," but I enjoyed the fast movement that the frame allowed. Without it, the plot when have needed much more detail and description. The snapshots took the place of all of that, which I found a refreshing shift from our other readings.
Thanks!
B